My Ranking of the 10 Greatest Fights in NHL History (Why They Mattered)

I’ve watched teeth fly across the Plexiglas. I’ve heard the dull, sickening thud of a bare knuckle connecting with a cheekbone from three rows up in the press box. Purists hate it. Commissioners try to legislate it out of existence. But let’s not kid ourselves—fighting is woven deep into the brutal, beautiful DNA of professional hockey. Over decades covering this sport, I’ve noticed a shift. The staged heavyweight bouts are dying out, replaced by speed and analytics. That makes looking back at the real wars even more critical. These weren’t just petty tantrums on ice. They were psychological chess matches, momentum swingers, and sometimes, cultural watersheds that defined eras. Trust me on this: to understand the modern NHL, you have to stomach its violent past. Here is my definitive ranking of the ten greatest fights in league history, and more importantly, why they actually mattered.

10. Tie Domi vs. Bob Probert (1992) – The Standard of Chaos

Let’s start with a clinic in sheer physical defiance. Tie Domi was a bowling ball of muscle who routinely punched way above his weight class. Bob Probert was the undisputed king of the mountain—a terrifying mix of size, reach, and relentless pressure. When these two squared off in March 1992, nobody expected a tactical masterpiece. We got a demolition derby instead. Domi caught Probert early, Probert answered with terrifying right hands, and by the end, both men were exhausted gladiators trading punches to a roaring crowd. It mattered because it proved that heart could occasionally neutralize raw physical dominance, setting a high-water mark for the enforcer era.

9. Simon vs. Hollweg (2007) – The Dark Turning Point

Here’s the ugly truth: fighting hasn’t always been noble. Sometimes it crosses the line into pure ugliness. Chris Simon’s vicious two-handed hack and subsequent stomp on Ryan Hollweg’s face during a 2007 Islanders-Rangers tilt was brutal. Why rank it? Because it mattered as a catalyst. It forced the league to look in the mirror and finally reckon with the darker, unchecked side of code-enforcing. It sparked massive policy shifts regarding supplementary discipline and began the slow, inevitable dismantling of the goon era. It’s a dark entry, but a vital one.

8. Rick Rypien vs. Jim Vandermeer (2009) – David and Goliath

Size means nothing if you possess absolute, unhinged fearlessness. Rick Rypien stood just 5-foot-11, yet he routinely hunted the league’s heavyweights. Against Jim Vandermeer, Rypien didn’t just fight—he orchestrated a blitzkrieg. He ducked, countered, and landed with shocking velocity before dragging Vandermeer to the ice. It mattered because it showed how a single, undersized player could completely rewrite the energy of a struggling bench. Vancouver needed a spark, and Rypien provided a bonfire.

7. Brendan Shanahan vs. Craig Berube (1991) – Pure Hockey Royalty Meets the Muscle

People forget that elite goalscorers used to drop the gloves. Brendan Shanahan was a Hall of Fame talent who could snipe from anywhere, but he also possessed zero hesitation about answering the bell. Craig Berube was an absolute nightmare for opponents. When they locked horns, it was a 1980s-style heavyweight title fight disguised as a regular-season game. It mattered because it shattered the myth that skill players couldn’t or wouldn’t protect themselves. Shanahan earned universal respect across the Hockey Hall of Fame track with performances like this.

6. Milan Lucic vs. Mike Komisarek (2009) – Changing of the Guard

Montreal was hosting Boston in a playoff atmosphere during the regular season, and tensions reached a boiling point. Milan Lucic was a young wrecking ball for the Bruins; Mike Komisarek was the Canadiens’ veteran physical presence. Lucic unleashed a flurry of devastating lefts that literally cracked Komisarek’s orbital bone. It mattered because it signaled a definitive shift in power within the historic Bruins-Canadiens rivalry. Boston was suddenly bigger, meaner, and entirely unafraid.

5. Marty McSorley vs. Donald Brashear (2000) – The Legacy That Broke the Code

This is the fight that changed the legal landscape of hockey. McSorley’s two-handed slash to Brashear’s head wasn’t just a hockey fight; it was an assault that led to criminal conviction. It mattered because it forced the NHL to realize that on-ice violence had legal boundaries. It changed how veterans approached the unwritten “code” and accelerated the conversation around player safety, leading directly to stricter helmet mandates and harsher penalties for stick work.

4. Rob Ray vs. Tie Domi (1995) – The Birth of the “Jersey Rule”

Tie Domi makes another appearance, this time against Rob Ray, the master of the sweater-off defensive maneuver. Ray famously unbuckled his jersey so opponents couldn’t grab it to gain leverage. When they fought in ’95, it turned into a bizarre, half-naked wrestling match that had the Igloo crowd losing its collective mind. It mattered because it forced the NHL to implement the “Ray Stopper” rule, requiring jerseys to be tied down securely. Bureaucracy was born out of pure chaos.

3. Ray Emery vs. Braden Holtby (2013) – Goalies Gone Wild

Goalie fights are rare unicorns. Goalie fights where one netminder skates the entire length of the ice to hunt down an unwilling counterpart are legendary. Ray Emery skated down, grabbed Braden Holtby, and threw him to the ice in a one-sided beatdown. Fans ate it up. Critics called it embarrassing. It mattered because it was the ultimate peak of the Philadelphia Flyers’ modern broad street bully identity—chaotic, theatrical, and utterly unforgettable.

2. Terry O’Reilly vs. Dave Schultz (1977) – The Clash of Titans

If you weren’t around for the late 70s, you simply cannot fathom the sheer terror inspired by Dave “The Hammer” Schultz. He was the enforcer for the Broad Street Bullies. Terry O’Reilly was Boston’s ultimate protector. When these two icons finally collided, it was like two tectonic plates grinding together. Punches were thrown with murderous intent. It mattered because it defined the golden age of NHL intimidation, proving that mental warfare was just as important as the scoreboard.

1. Patrick Roy vs. Mike Vernon / Chris Osgood (1996 & 1997) – The Ultimate Rivalry Pinnacle

Topping the list isn’t just a single bout, but the goalie wars of the Colorado-Detroit rivalry. Patrick Roy tackling Mike Vernon, and later trading punches with Chris Osgood at center ice, transcended sports. These weren’t anonymous fourth-line enforcers earning their keep; these were Hall of Fame goaltenders, carrying the hopes of entire cities, shedding their blockers to throw haymakers. It mattered because it captured the absolute zenith of the most heated, vicious rivalry in modern sports history. When your goaltender is willing to bleed at center ice, your team has no excuse not to win.

Frequently Asked Questions